This is a specific conversation about Dog treats — what's worth giving — ask about yours and get one honest answer for your exact situation.
inparticular.ai
So you're moving away from soft training treats and want something with a bit more substance — good call. The best treats are high in protein, low in additives, and sized right for the dog. Most popular training treats are heavily marketed but nutritionally thin, full of fillers and preservatives. Single-ingredient dried meat or fish skin treats are almost always the better option — more satisfying, cleaner ingredients, and dogs tend to work harder for them. To point you to the right thing: how big is your Vizsla, any allergies or sensitivities, and are these still going to be used in training sessions or more for general rewards?
He's about 25kg, no known allergies. Still using them in training but I want something he has to actually chew a bit rather than just inhale. He goes through the soft ones in half a second and I think it's too easy for him.
inparticular.ai
That makes complete sense — a 2-year-old Vizsla with soft treats is basically pressing a button, there's no engagement at all. You want something that takes a second or two to work through, which also slows the reward down and makes it feel more substantial to him. What are the training sessions like — duration, intensity, how many treats per session roughly?
Usually 15 to 20 minutes, fairly high intensity, recall and off-lead work. He probably gets 20 to 30 treats in a session so they can't be too big or rich either.
inparticular.ai
Perfect detail. At 20 to 30 treats a session you need something that won't tip his diet sideways, so richness and calorie density matter. Dried liver is the sweet spot — chewy enough to take a genuine bite, but you can break it into pieces small enough that the total intake stays reasonable across a session. For a 25kg dog doing serious off-lead work, I'd go with Natural Instinct Pure Beef Liver treats. Single ingredient, air-dried, firm enough that he'll actually chew rather than inhale, and you can snap them into the size you want. Vizslas tend to go absolutely mad for liver, which helps when you're competing with distractions outdoors.
That sounds good. Are they easy to break up in your pocket or do they crumble everywhere?
inparticular.ai
They snap cleanly rather than crumble — you can break them before the session and carry the pieces loose in a treat pouch without ending up with powder in your pocket. They're firm but not rock hard, so no issue snapping them mid-session either if you need smaller pieces. One thing worth knowing: dried liver is quite rich, so if he's not used to it start with a smaller amount in the first couple of sessions and build up. Most dogs are fine, but sensitive stomachs occasionally need a few days to adjust.
That's really helpful, I'll give them a try. Thanks.
inparticular.ai
Good luck with the recall work — Natural Instinct Pure Beef Liver is a solid switch and I think you'll notice the difference in how he engages with the reward. Enjoy the sessions.