This is a specific conversation about Dog recall training — tools and treats that help — ask about yours and get one honest answer for your exact situation.
inparticular.ai
Making the switch from a choke chain to positive training is one of the best decisions you can make for a Pointer — they're sensitive, intelligent dogs and they respond really well once you rebuild that trust. Reliable recall is honestly the most important skill any dog can have, and for a breed with that prey drive, getting it solid is non-negotiable. A high-value treat paired with a long line for safe off-lead practice is usually the fastest route there. To point you to the right setup: how old is your Pointer and how bad is the recall right now — does he come back sometimes, or is it basically non-existent once he's locked onto a scent? And are you after training aids, treats, or both?
He's 4 years old, a German Wirehaired Pointer called Bram. Recall is pretty bad honestly — he'll come back in the garden but the second we're in a field and he catches a scent he's gone. I've been using a choke chain for two years and I can tell he just associates it with being yanked back, not actually choosing to come. I want to start fresh with a long line and treats but I don't really know where to begin.
inparticular.ai
That makes total sense — what you're describing is a dog who's never really learned that coming back is his idea and that good things happen when he does. The choke chain creates avoidance, not recall. At 4 he's got established habits, so you'll need to be consistent, but Wirehaired Pointers are smart and once the penny drops it tends to stick. Before I give you a specific recommendation — what are his absolute favourite treats? Does he go wild for something specific like sausage or cheese, or have you not really found his 'thing' yet?
He goes absolutely mental for cooked chicken. I've used it in the garden and he's laser focused. Just never tried it on the long line outside yet.
inparticular.ai
Perfect — chicken is as good as it gets for a working breed like Bram. Here's exactly what I'd start with: get the Trixie Tracking Leash in 15 metres. It's a flat biothane-style long line with a swivel clip, lightweight enough that Bram won't feel burdened by it, and 15 metres gives you real distance to let him range without losing control when he hits a scent. The length is important — too short and you're not building anything, too long and it becomes unmanageable. Clip it to a well-fitted harness, not a collar, so there's no neck pressure if he hits the end. Then do short sessions in low-distraction fields first: let him drift out, call his name once in a happy voice, and the moment he turns toward you, start reeling in the line with enthusiasm and reward with chicken the second he reaches you. Don't repeat the command, don't chase him. Every recall gets chicken. After two to three weeks of this, his muscle memory starts to shift — coming back becomes the default.
That sounds really manageable actually. Should I be worried about the line tangling or getting caught on things? We train in fields with some rough grass.
inparticular.ai
It's a fair concern but a flat biothane line handles it much better than a round rope one — it doesn't snag on grass nearly as badly and it wipes clean easily which matters when you're in muddy fields. The main thing is to keep a loose coil in your hand rather than letting the full 15 metres drag behind him — feed it out as he moves and take it back in when he closes the distance. You'll get the hang of it within a session or two. One practical tip: wear gloves for the first few sessions. If he hits the end at speed the line can burn.
Really useful, thank you. So just to confirm — Trixie 15m tracking leash, attached to a harness, chicken rewards, and start in quieter fields before building up distraction?
inparticular.ai
Exactly that. Trixie 15m tracking leash on a harness, real chicken cut small so he's getting a lot of repetitions without filling up, and start somewhere boring before you go anywhere with wildlife or other dogs. The goal in the first few weeks isn't testing recall — it's just building the habit that your voice means something brilliant is about to happen. Once that association is solid, the distractions become much easier to work through. Bram will get there.