Best value cat treats for two cats on a budget

Feeding two cats on one income means every bag needs to earn its place — and with cats being famously picky, you really don't want to waste money on treats they'll just sniff and walk away from. Cats tend to go for strongly-scented, meat-based treats and often flat-out refuse anything sweet or grain-heavy, so the best value is actually in high-protein options with minimal fillers — they're more appealing, so a little goes further. Before I point you toward something, is this for training, general rewarding, or enrichment? And does either cat have any dietary needs I should know about — your Manx in particular?

That's helpful — and honestly a straightforward brief. For two healthy cats where you want reliable appeal and good cost-per-treat, can I ask: are both cats already eating any treats you've tried before, or are you starting fresh? I want to know if either of them has already rejected something, because that'll help me steer you right.

That's really useful. A Manx rejecting dry crunchy supermarket treats is very common — they often lack the meaty scent cats respond to, so the cat just isn't interested. Your Manx will almost certainly do better with something that has a stronger smell and a softer texture. My recommendation is the Dreamies Mega Tube — 350g for around £4 to £5, which works out to excellent value per treat. They're semi-moist, intensely chicken-scented, and consistently one of the best-accepted treats across fussy cats. Both cats should go for them, and the large tube means you're not constantly rebuying. Use them sparingly — they're designed as a small daily reward, not a main food — and they'll last well.

Usually yes, though it's worth a quick check on the day you buy. The mega tube typically works out cheaper per gram than the standard 60g bags even in multipacks, and you avoid the extra packaging waste. The one advantage of multipacks is variety — different flavours keep some cats more engaged — but given your Manx is already a bit fussy, I'd start with the single mega tube in chicken to confirm she likes it before experimenting. Once you know she's on board, the multipacks become a reasonable option down the line.

Great choice — straightforward, cost-effective, and the right fit for a fussy cat and a relaxed one living together. The Dreamies Mega Tube in chicken is one of those products that reliably delivers, and at that size it'll keep both of them happy for a good while without denting the budget.